Blog

The Controversy of Third-Party Restaurant Food Delivery Services

Jay Bandy • January 9, 2022

How this "necessary evil" is evolving for restaurant operators

Two-wheel food delivery vehicle with driver in city environment

The demand for food delivery services increased when COVID-19 emerged. These third-party delivery services provided an independent delivery personnel to deliver food to customers through their apps with a delivery fee and tip for the delivery driver.

Most restaurants benefitted from these third-party food delivery services, but other restaurants did not have the same success rate. According to Mary King, “third-party food delivery services have setup fees of up to $400, charge a commission of 10% to 40% per order, and may not integrate with your point-of-sale system.”1

Restaurants are not opposed to using third-party delivery apps if that means they have gained new customers through them, but what happens when these customers are not willing to spend the extra fees to have their food delivered to them? What happens if the independent driver of these third-party food delivery services is not given a tip because the customers do not believe in tipping if there is a delivery fee?

The positive side of third-party delivery services

Food delivery through third-party services is very popular among Millennials, Gen-Z, and busy working parents. Food delivery services are not the quickest or cheapest, but it is popular because of the convenience it provides for consumers.

“A 2021 study by Buyer’s Edge Platform found, 42.3% of consumers still prefer eating takeout or delivery at home.”2

Companies such as GrubHub, DoorDash, Postmates, and Uber Eats have been growing in popularity, more so now during the pandemic. “According to a study conducted by Zion & Zion, 63% of young adults use third-party delivery apps.”3

In addition, using these delivery services also opens marketing opportunities for restaurants. Many of these companies provide services in which allow restaurants to gain loyal followers in the delivery service with the use of discounts and other loyalty strategies.

If a restaurant is new, marketing themselves on these delivery services allows the restaurant to gain another target audience. For example, DoorDash may notify its users in the area that the restaurant has opened and is on DoorDash.

Moreover, to further promote your restaurant on these apps, “you can pay extra for priority placement, promoted listings, and featured offerings.”4 On GrubHub, a restaurant using their marketing commission can increase their visibility on the app by 20%, for example.5

The negative side of third-party delivery services

Some restaurateurs claim that third-party delivery services are doing more harm than good. After commissions and fees, it can cost consumers and providers up to 30-40% more.6

During the pandemic, these third-party delivery services were putting a hold on delivery fees to help aid in the pandemic, but ever since restrictions have been lifted, these delivery fees have come back and are more expensive than ever.

Customers using these apps have complained that the delivery fee is too high and ridiculous. They claim it serves no purpose because most of these delivery fees do not go towards the driver at all, which means customers still must add on an additional tip.

Customers are reluctant to tip their drivers through these third-party delivery services. Some are not aware that the delivery fees do not go directly to the independent driver, or they know and do not care enough to put in a tip.

Furthermore, this hurts the drivers and the restaurant in which the order was placed at. When drivers get an order notification, they can only see how much the order is. After they choose to accept the order, they can then see how much they will be paid in tips.

For drivers, they will be angry that they did not receive a tip and continue the order depending on whether they will still get paid a specific rate provided by the third-party service. However, some choose to cancel the order, which will result in the customer waiting longer to receive their food, resulting in it getting cold.

Having said that, if no one is willing to accept the order, restaurants will have to throw away the order that was not picked up, which results in a waste of ingredients and supplies. In addition, “a survey of 42,000 people by Service Management Group found that 35% of customers experienced a problem when using a third-party delivery service, and almost half of them faulted the restaurant.”7

Other third-party delivery services

Ways in which restaurants can still provide delivery services are through smaller third-party services. Smaller third-party services do not overcharge restaurants for commission, and some have little to no delivery fee depending on where the restaurant is in a specific area.

A few examples include ChowNow and Toast. ChowNow is an online ordering platform in which restaurants can easily use to manage delivery or pickup orders. The company does not charge for delivery fees. Instead, they charge flat rate monthly fees – “$99 a month for a two-year plan (plus a $199 setup fee), $119 a month for an annual plan (plus a $199 setup fee) and $149 a month for a monthly plan (plus a $399 setup fee).”8

In addition, Toast is a restaurant technology sales company. However, when COVID-19 emerged, the company developed Toast TakeOut, which allows for customers to order their food online, pay in advance, and pick up their order from the restaurant themselves. Toast TakeOut does not charge restaurants any software fees if they are participating in using the Toast Online Ordering product.

Should restaurants continue using third-party delivery services?

The use of third-party delivery services is dependent on the restaurant and how much they are willing to pay for these services. It may be best for restaurants to use smaller food delivery companies, but this may not help the restaurant gain visibility or provide a larger scale of marketing services.

Furthermore, consider your restaurant’s demographics. There are some well-known delivery services in which cater to a specific target audience such as Black-owned restaurants.

It is also important to note whether the third-party delivery service will integrate well with your POS. If not, consider how easy it is to make changes to the system such as menus and prices.

Overall, delivery should always be something restaurants should consider because most people are looking for convenience now.

References
1. https://fitsmallbusiness.com/pros-cons-third-party-delivery-services/
2. https://www.touchbistro.com/blog/third-party-food-delivery-services/
3. https://www.forbes.com/sites/stevenbeagelman/2020/07/24/third-party-delivery-is-more-important-than-...
4. https://fitsmallbusiness.com/pros-cons-third-party-delivery-services/
5. Ibid
6. https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesfinancecouncil/2020/05/04/why-food-delivery-companies-may-be-doin...
7. https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesfinancecouncil/2020/05/04/why-food-delivery-companies-may-be-doin...
8. https://www.today.com/food/top-alternative-delivery-sites-aim-help-local-restaurants-t208001

By Jay Bandy May 12, 2026
How operators and owners can prevent back of house food waste at their restaurants
By Jay Bandy May 8, 2026
Atlanta restaurant owners should prepare now for the massive business opportunities tied to FIFA World Cup 2026.
By Jay Bandy May 6, 2026
A complete Mother’s Day operations strategy for restaurant operators, covering BOH prep, FOH execution, staffing, and profitability insights.
people with phones taking pictures of food in a restaurant
By Jay Bandy May 4, 2026
social media and restaurants
By Jay Bandy April 27, 2026
How to create authenticity in restaurant marketing campaigns to stand out to customers and attract more business
By Jay Bandy April 23, 2026
Learn how strategic restaurant interior design influences guest experience, boosts revenue, and builds brand loyalty through lighting, layout, color, and atmosphere.
By Jay Bandy April 20, 2026
Discover a strategic framework for restaurant partnership marketing that drives revenue growth, strengthens community engagement, and increases brand visibility through local collaborations, seasonal promotions, and data-driven performance tracking.
By Jay Bandy April 17, 2026
In today’s competitive restaurant landscape, attention is currency. With consumers spending more time on platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube, restaurant operators must meet guests where they are—and increasingly, that means leveraging influencer marketing as a core strategy. According to Businesswire, 81% of consumers report researching or purchasing a product or service after seeing social media content from influencers, friends, or family. Additionally, QSR Magazine has reported that restaurants utilizing influencer partnerships can generate an average of $6.50 in revenue for every $1 spent—a 650% return on investment. For operators focused on measurable ROI, this is no longer a trend—it’s a strategic channel. Why Influencer Marketing Works in Restaurants At its core, influencer marketing works because of trust and relatability. Guests are more likely to try a restaurant based on a recommendation from someone they follow and engage with regularly. Unlike traditional advertising, influencer content feels organic, personal, and experience-driven. A strong example is The Halal Guys, which gained significant traction after being featured by food influencers as “the best street food in NYC.” That exposure, combined with user-generated content and word-of-mouth, helped scale the brand into an international concept. For restaurant operators, the takeaway is clear: influencer marketing can accelerate brand awareness, drive trial, and amplify digital presence when executed correctly. Identifying the Right Influencers One of the most common mistakes operators make is selecting influencers based solely on follower count. In reality, alignment matters more than reach. Operators should evaluate: • Content niche (e.g., casual dining, vegan, upscale, budget-friendly) • Audience demographics and geography • Engagement rates (comments, shares, saves—not just likes) • Content quality and storytelling ability An influencer who aligns with your brand positioning will deliver far more value than one with a larger but less relevant audience. Micro vs. Macro Influencers Understanding influencer tiers is critical for budgeting and campaign planning. Micro-influencers (10,000–100,000 followers): • Higher engagement rates • More authentic and community-driven content • Lower cost per post • Ideal for local restaurant marketing and multi-unit campaigns Macro-influencers (100,000–1M+ followers): • Broader reach and brand visibility • Higher production quality • Higher cost • Best suited for brand launches or regional/national campaigns For most restaurant groups, especially those operating in the 1–20 unit range, micro-influencers provide the most efficient return on marketing spend. Best Practices for Working with Influencers Avoid scripting content Authenticity drives performance. Influencers understand their audience and voice—overly scripted content will reduce engagement and credibility. Provide structured brand guidelines Instead of scripts, provide clear expectations: • Key messaging points • Brand positioning • Deliverables (posts, reels, stories) • Do’s and don’ts Treat influencers as strategic partners Influencers are not just guests—they are content creators working on your behalf. Ensure: • Complimentary dining experience • Seamless access to food and environment • Clear communication before, during, and after the visit Measure performance Track KPIs such as: • Engagement rate • Reach and impressions • Click-throughs (if applicable) • Sales lift during campaign windows Integrating influencer marketing into your broader marketing stack—alongside email, loyalty, paid media, and reputation management—creates a more comprehensive growth strategy. Conclusion Influencer marketing is no longer optional for restaurant operators looking to remain competitive in today’s digital-first environment. When executed strategically—with the right partners, clear guidelines, and measurable goals—it can drive meaningful traffic, increase brand awareness, and deliver strong financial returns. Author Bio Jay Bandy is President of Goliath Consulting Group, a leading restaurant consulting firm based in Atlanta, Georgia. With over 30 years of experience in restaurant operations, development, and growth strategy, Jay specializes in helping multi-unit restaurant brands improve profitability, scale efficiently, and implement data-driven marketing and operational systems. Goliath Consulting Group works with independent operators and regional chains across the Southeast and nationwide. To learn more about our services including menu development, business strategy, marketing, and restaurant operations, contact us at http://www.goliathconsulting.com or email us at getresults@goliathconsulting.com
April 15, 2026
Restaurant concept marketing has been a core pillar of the Goliath Business Model for over 16 years. Over that span, we’ve seen which marketing trends come and go, and which have lasting positive impacts for restaurant operators. From social media campaigns to strategic restaurant website design and public relations initiatives, Goliath Consulting has consistently helped restaurants not only attract attention but convert that marketing traction into real loyal customers. One of the biggest challenges restaurants face today is cutting through the digital noise. With countless brands competing for visibility online, it’s not enough to simply have a social media presence or a website. Restaurant marketing strategies need to be intentional, relevant, and results‑focused. This is where Goliath Consulting excels. We don’t just create content and marketing plans: we craft long‑term growth blueprints that turn the digital landscape into a revenue generator for your location. According to a 2022 academic study on digital marketing in the restaurant industry, social media, online branding, and online advertisements have a significant impact on restaurants’ competitiveness, helping them attract customers and enabling them to perform better against competitors who don’t use these tools as effectively. Leading the charge on these efforts is Adam Warmouth, Goliath Consulting’s Communications and Marketing Specialist. Adam brings over six years of hands‑on experience helping both small businesses and franchise owners stand out in crowded markets. His approach is defined by bold creativity, strategic insight, and a focus on measurable outcomes.
By Jay Bandy April 14, 2026
Learn how restaurant owners can create Instagram-worthy restaurants that boost guest engagement, drive traffic, and increase revenue through shareable dining experiences.